Volume 68
Why Some Religious Accommodations for Mandatory Vaccinations Violate the Establishment Clause
Hillel Y. Levin Volume 68, Issue 6, 1193-1242 All states require parents to inoculate their children against deadly diseases prior to enrolling them in public schools, but the vast majority of states also allow parents to opt out on religious...
Bad Reliance in Public Law
Michal Saliternik Volume 68, Issue 6, 1243-1290 When and how should courts protect individual reliance upon unlawful governmental acts? This question arises in various situations in all fields of public law. However, despite its pervasiveness,...
Improving Services for Those Who Served: Practical Recommendations for the Department of Veterans Affairs’ Disability Benefits Model
Scott W. Taylor Volume 68, Issue 6, 1291-1318 The mission of the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (“VA”) is “[t]o care for him who shall have borne the battle, and for his widow, and his orphan” by providing services and benefits to...
Sex, Drones & Videotape: Rethinking Copyright’s Authorship-Fixation Conflation in the Age of Performance
John Tehranian Volume 68, Issue 6, 1319-1370 For more than two centuries, the Copyright Act has eschewed the task of defining authorship. However, with the decoupling of the act of creation from the act of fixation and the dramatic advance of...
Big Data, Price Discrimination, and Antitrust
Ramsi A. Woodcock Volume 68, Issue 6, 1371-1420 Antitrust law today guarantees a particular distribution of wealth between consumers and firms by promoting competition in some markets, but allowing firms to retain pricing power in other...
The National Bank Act and the Demise of State Consumer Laws
Angel Rzeslawski Volume 68, Issue 6, 1421-1440 Following the financial crises of 2008, the Dodd-Frank Act was signed into law to protect consumers from abusive financial services among other things. However, the Dodd-Frank Act has a...
Examining the Conditions of Confinement for Civil Detainees Under California’s Sexually Violent Predators Act
Dana Sherman Volume 68, Issue 6, 1441-1460 “Civil detainees” under the Sexually Violent Predators Act include those persons who have already served their criminal sentences, but are still caged in prisons, awaiting court determination of...
The Demand for Fiduciary Services: Evidence from the Market in Private Donative Trusts
Adam Hofri-Winogradow Volume 68, Issue 5, 931-1006 Recent revelations on the use of fiduciary services raise concerns regarding their use for tax and creditor avoidance. Yet given the secrecy shrouding much of the fiduciary industry, we do not...
Minority Mens Rea: Racial Bias and Criminal Mental States
Francis X. Shen Volume 68, Issue 5, 1007-1084 The American criminal justice system relies upon jurors to regularly decode the mental states of criminal defendants. These determinations are often of black and Hispanic defendants, making...
Regulation Through Deregulation: Sharing Economy Companies Gaining Legitimacy by Circumventing Traditional Frameworks
Diana Cao Volume 68, Issue 5, 1085-1110 The “sharing economy” is a term describing organized economic activity that may supplant the traditional corporate-centered model and encourages peer-to-peer transactions. It is a system of sharing...
International Data Transfers: The Effect of Divergent Cultural Views in Privacy Causes Déjà Vu
Alyssa Coley Volume 68, Issue 5, 1111-1134 Whether operating globally or simply integrating services on the Internet, many business functions inevitably subject companies to a web of complicated international regulatory and legal requirements....
The Right to Dignity in the United States
Michelle Freeman Volume 68, Issue 5, 1135-1168 Under the law, “dignity” is a principle that is often invoked, but ill-defined. The most recent and prominent example of this was the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Obergefell v. Hodges. There,...
“Let’s Play”: YouTube and Twitch’s Video Game Footage and a New Approach to Fair Use
Conrad Postel Volume 68, Issue 5, 1169-1192 Some of the most watched user-created videos on the Internet are recordings of individuals playing video games. These are commonly referred to as “Let’s Play” videos. The revenue that these videos can...
California Constitutional Law: Popular Sovereignty
David A. Carrillo Volume 68, Issue 4, 731-776 In 1911, the California Constitution was amended to divide the state’s legislative power by reserving to the electorate the powers of initiative, referendum, and recall. Most of the thinking to date...
Big Data and the Americans with Disabilities Act
Sharona Hoffman Volume 68, Issue 4, 777-794 While big data offers society many potential benefits, it also comes with serious risks. This Article focuses on the concern that big data will lead to increased employment discrimination. It develops...
The Life and Legacy of Professor Calvin R. Massey: A Select Annotated Bibliography
Nicholas Mignanelli Volume 68, Issue 4, 795-816 Professor Calvin R. Massey served on the faculty of the University of California, Hastings College of the Law from 1987 until 2012. From 2012 until his death in 2015, he served as the inaugural...
Grasping Fatherhood in Abortion and Adoption
Malinda L. Seymore Volume 68, Issue 4, 817-868 Biology makes a mother, but it does not make a father. While a mother is a legal parent by reason of her biological relationship with her child, a father is not a legal parent unless he takes...
Daddy or Donor? Uncertainty in California Law in the Wake of Jason P. v. Danielle S.
Amy Leah Holtz Volume 68, Issue 4, 869-908 The era of technology has provided a proliferation of new scientific and technological methods designed to assist individuals and couples to successfully conceive children when they otherwise would not...
The Reality of International Commercial Arbitration in California
Victoria Vlahoyiannis Volume 68, Issue 4, 909-930 California is one of the largest economies in the world. It is home to many of the most successful companies in all sectors, especially health and technology. In recent years arbitration...
The Deregulation of Private Capital and the Decline of the Public Company
Elisabeth de Fontenay Volume 68, Issue 3, 445-502 From its inception, the federal securities law regime created and enforced a major divide between public and private capital raising. Firms that chose to “go public” took on substantial...
“Strangers in a Strange Land”: Chinese Companies in the American Tax System
Ji Li Volume 68, Issue 3, 503-540 Foreign direct investment (“FDI”) from emerging economies generally exhibits two distinct characteristics: (1) most of the investors thrive in poor regulatory environments, and (2) the visible hand of the state...
Law in Hiding: Market Principles in the Global Legal Order
Odette Lienau Volume 68, Issue 3, 541-608 Standing in the background of the global legal order are a range of what might be called “market principles” or “market givens”collective presentations or beliefs about how markets workwhich are...
Migration Emergencies
Jaya Ramji-Nogales Volume 68, Issue 3, 609-656 Migration emergencies are a commonplace feature in contemporary headlines. Pundits offer a variety of causes provoking these emergencies. Some highlight the deadly risks of these journeys for the...
Making It Up: Lessons for Equal Protection Doctrine from the Use and Abuse of Hypothesized Purposes in the Marriage Equality Litigation
Steve Sanders Volume 68, Issue 3, 657-710 To survive rational basis scrutiny under the Equal Protection Clause, a law must serve a governmental purpose which is at least legitimate. It is well established that legitimate purposes can sometimes...
The Modern Legal Status of Frozen Embryos
Alyssa Yoshida Volume 68, Issue 3, 711-730 With the help of modern technology, people today have more flexibility than ever before in the realm of family planning and conceiving children. An increasing amount of couples are opting to go through...
Patriarchy, Not Hierarchy: Rethinking the Effect of Cultural Attitudes in Acquaintance Rape Cases
Eric R. Carpenter Volume 68, Issue 2, 225-258 Do certain people view acquaintance rape cases in ways that favor the man? The answer to that question is important. If certain people do, and those people form a disproportionately large percentage...
How the Constitution Became Christian
Jared A. Goldstein Volume 68, Issue 2, 259-308 Movements dedicated to making the United States a “Christian nation” have been a recurrent feature in American politics for more than 150 years. Over that time, however, the relationship between...
Smart Cities, Big Data, and the Resilience of Privacy
Janine S. Hiller and Jordan M. Blanke Volume 68, Issue 2, 309-56 Smart Cities are designed to ubiquitously collect information about people, places, and activities and to use that data to provide more efficient services and to build resilience...
Trade Secret Precautions, Possession, and Notice
Deepa Varadarajan Volume 68, Issue 2, 357-96 To obtain trade secret protection, a firm must take reasonable secrecy precautions (“RSP”) to guard the confidentiality of claimed information. The RSP requirement has long puzzled courts and...
Correcting Computer Vision: The Case for Real Eyes After Lenz
M. Jake Feaver Volume 68, Issue 2, 397-418 The internet brought plentiful opportunities for sharing content between individuals. However, along with those opportunities, the potential for abuse and intellectual property infringement increased...
Changing Tides for Captive Marine Mammals: What the Future Holds for Captive Care Requirements
Isabella Langone Volume 68, Issue 2, 419-44 When the marine mammal entertainment industry emerged in the 1960s, companies like SeaWorld captured orcas and dolphins from the wild and put the animals on display to bring joy and entertainment to...
Contextual Healing: What to Do About Scandalous Trademarks and Lanham Act 2(a)
Megan M. Carpenter Volume 68, Issue 1, 1-44 Offensive trademarks have come to the forefront of trademark policy and practice in recent years. While it was once true that more attention had been paid to Lanham Act section 2(a) in the pages of...
The Define and Punish Clause and the Political Question Doctrine
Lyle D. Kossis Volume 68, Issue 1, 45-96 The Constitution gives Congress the power to “define and punish . . . Offences against the Law of Nations.” Congress has used this power to enact various criminal statutes that proscribe certain...
The “New Insiders”: Rethinking Independent Directors’ Tenure
Yaron Nili Volume 68, Issue 1, 97-158 Director independence is a cornerstone of modern corporate governance. Regulators, scholars, companies, and shareholders have all placed a strong emphasis on director independence as a means to ensure that...
Far from the Madding Crowd: A Statutory Solution to Crowd Crush
Tracy Hresko Pearl Volume 68, Issue 1, 159-202 Crowd-related injuries and deaths occur with surprising frequency in the United States. In recent years, crowd members in the United States have sustained significant injuries and even fatalities...
A Bridge over the Patent Trolls: Using Antitrust Laws to Rein in Patent Aggregators
Eric Young Volume 68, Issue 1, 203-24 Patents, by their very nature, are a type of monopoly, and are so important to our country’s intellectual and technological advancement that the Founding Fathers granted Congress the power “to promote the...