Volume 74
Governmental and Semi-Governmental Federal Charitable Entities
Ellen P. Aprill Volume 74, Issue 6, 1555-1620 The standard view of the relationship between government and the nonprofit charitable sector treats them as separate and distinct. But they are not. Numerous federal agencies have statutory authority to receive...
Interstate Immunity and the Uncompleted Constitution
Mark D. Rosen Volume 74, Issue 6, 1621-1682 In a recent decision, the Supreme Court held that “the founding generation took as a given” that states would be constitutionally immune to suit in the courts of sister states, overruling an earlier ruling that interstate...
“Engines of the Ruling Party”: The Establishment Clause and the Power Politics of “Managing Diversity”
Robert A. Destro Volume 74, Issue 6, 1683-1750 “Constitutional lawsuits are the stuff of power politics in America. The Court may be, and usually is, above party politics and personal politics, but the politics of power is a most important and delicate function, and...
Religious Liberty as a Judicial Autoimmune Disorder: The Supreme Court Repudiates Its Own Authority in Kennedy v. Bremerton School District
Andrew Koppelman Volume 74, Issue 6, 1751-1762 Today’s Supreme Court is so predisposed to find discrimination against religion that it declared it to be present in a case where the discriminator was obeying the Court’s own commands. In Kennedy v. Bremerton School...
The Remains of the Establishment Clause
Ira C. Lupu & Robert W. Tuttle Volume 74, Issue 6, 1763-1812 The very first words of the Bill of Rights mark religion as constitutionally distinctive. Congress may not enact laws respecting an establishment of religion—in particular, acts of worship, religious...
The New Fourth Era of American Religious Freedom
John Witte, Jr. & Eric Wang Volume 74, Issue 6, 1813-1848 The U.S. Supreme Court has entered decisively into a new fourth era of American religious freedom. In the first era, from 1776 to 1940, the Court largely left governance of religious freedom to the...
Debt as Corporate Governance
Tomer S. Stein Volume 74, Issue 5, 1281-1330 Corporate law is dominated by an equity-only view of corporate governance that centers on management-shareholder dynamics. This Article expands the management-shareholder paradigm by developing a novel integrated theory of...
The Ethics of Defense Counsel’s Communications with Absent Class Members Before Class Certification
Candice Enders & Joshua P. Davis Volume 74, Issue 5, 1331-1352 Attention to how courts address the ethics of defense counsel’s communications with absent class members before class certification is valuable for two primary reasons. First, it provides insight into...
The Ethics Gap: MDL Leadership Versus the Attorney-Client Relationship
Lauren E. Godshall Volume 74, Issue 5, 1353-1372 Mass torts cases take up a massive swath of the nation’s federal court docket yet are governed by little to no substantive procedural laws. Instead, a host of regular practices for multidistrict litigation (“MDL”)...
Ethics by Appointment: An Empirical Account Obscured Sanctioning in MDL Cases
Roger Michalski Volume 74, Issue 5, 1373-1402 Ethical norms in litigation are policed through overlapping regulatory regimes. One of these regimes is internal to litigation and split into different components, including Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 11, 26(g), and...
Where Neutrality Stops and Reality Begins: Why Considering Identity Is Vital to Lead and Class Counsel Selection
Melissa Mortazavi Volume 74, Issue 5, 1403-1432 When courts consider a choice of class or lead counsel in multidistrict litigation (“MDL”) or class action suits, they often follow the idea of a neutral partisan model. Such a model idealizes lawyer conduct as a blank...
Class Actions’ Ethical “KISS”: The Class Action Lawyer’s Client Is the Class
Eli Wald Volume 74, Issue 5, 1433-1458 The legal ethics of class actions is a mess, with many lingering, unresolved questions and conflicting answers. The culprit is a fundamental lack of agreement regarding the identity of the client, without which it is impossible...
Complex Litigation Funding: Ethical Problem or Ethical Solution?
W. Bradley Wendel & Joshua P. Davis Volume 74, Issue 5, 1459-1482 Commentators have worried that third-party funding, particularly in complex litigation, may give rise to ethical concerns. In this Essay, we explore an alternative possibility: third-party funding...
Local Restrictions on Renewable Energy Siting in the United States
Jesse Honig Volume 74, Issue 5, 1483-1512 Climate change has arrived. The next decade will provide critical opportunities to avoid the most devastating impacts of climate change. The decisions we take over the next ten years will be the difference between moderate...
AI Proctoring: Academic Integrity vs. Student Rights
Samantha Mita Volume 74, Issue 5, 1513-1554 Advancements in artificial intelligence (“AI”) and machine learning have found their way into the classroom. The use of artificial intelligence proctoring services (“AIPS”) has risen over the past few years with little...
Compelling Trade Secret Sharing
David S. Levine & Joshua D. Sarnoff Volume 74, Issue 4, 987-1056 The unprecedented COVID-19 virus has brought to the forefront many challenges associated with exclusive rights in information, data, and know-how, all of which may constitute protected trade secrets....
Antitrust’s Healthcare Conundrum: Cross-Market Mergers and the Rise of System Power
Jaime S. King, Alexandra D. Montague, Daniel R. Arnold & Thomas L. Greaney Volume 74, Issue 4, 1057-1120 As healthcare markets continue to consolidate and prices continue to rise, economists, legal scholars, antitrust enforcers, and policymakers have the...
Science, Creativity, and the Copyright Clause
Ned Snow Volume 74, Issue 4, 1121-1166 The Constitution provides Congress the power to enact copyright laws in order “To promote the Progress of Science.” Some statements by the modern Supreme Court may be interpreted to suggest that “the Progress of Science” is...
Caremark’s Climate Failure
Andrew W. Winden Volume 74, Issue 4, 1167-1220 Unless U.S. corporations take steps to harden their assets against natural disasters exacerbated by climate change and prepare for the transition to a zero-carbon economy, they face the prospect of catastrophic risk to...
The Collapse of Alice’s Wonderland: Mayo’s Faulty Two-Step Framework and a Possible Solution to Patent-Eligibility Jurisprudence
Philip Hawkyard Volume 74, Issue 4, 1221-1250 In Mayo Collaborative Services v. Prometheus Laboratories, Inc., the Supreme Court established a two-step framework to determine whether a supposed invention that involves a “natural law” can be a patent-eligible subject...
Impact Jurisdiction & Structural Investigations: The Key to the United States Prosecuting Human Rights Violators
Nick Wiley Volume 74, Issue 4, 1251-1280 Since the turn of the century, there has been an exponential rise in forcibly displaced persons and human rights violations. This rise has coincided with a series of acts that have removed the United States as a global leader...
Privacy Theater in the Bankruptcy Courts
Christopher G. Bradley Volume 74, Issue 3, 607-678 The intersection between privacy law and the big business of consumer data has become a major focus of policymakers, scholars, the business community, and consumer advocates, yet the legal regime governing the...
Immigration Law’s Boundary Problem: Determining the Scope of Executive Discretion
Peter Margulies Volume 74, Issue 3, 679-764 In immigration law, executive discretion has become contested terrain. Courts, officials, and scholars have rarely distinguished between regulatory discretion, which facilitates exclusion and removal of noncitizens, and...
Loyalties v. Royalties
Sarah Polcz Volume 74, Issue 3, 765-822 Friendship rewards us with a bond of loyalty and equality. The marketplace rewards us based on what we have to offer. When friends work together to create something, and when the market judges their creation to have value, this...
The Surprisingly Strong Case for Local Income Taxes in the Era of Increased Remote Work
Erin Adele Scharff and Darien Shanske Volume 74, Issue 3, 823-868 Traditional theoretical literature on fiscal federalism urges cities to finance themselves with taxes on immobile sources. Thus, the literature sees real property taxes as the best source of local...
Mitigating Catastrophe Risk for Landowners
Stewart E. Sterk Volume 74, Issue 3, 869-910 Local, national, and global catastrophes entail significant risk for landowners. The government-sponsored National Flood Insurance Program illustrates how subsidizing insurance against catastrophe risk can result in...
Pole Cameras: Applying Fourth Amendment Protections to Emerging Surveillance Technology
Rahil Maharaj Volume 74, Issue 3, 911-934 Evolving surveillance technologies present unique challenges for the judiciary to maintain robust Fourth Amendment privacy protections. New surveillance tools such as pole cameras raise significant questions regarding the...
When Further Incarceration Is No Longer in the Interest of Justice: Instituting a Federal Prosecutor-Initiated Resentencing Framework
Lydia Tonozzi Volume 74, Issue 3, 935-958 The dire state of the prison population in the United States has become common knowledge both at home and abroad. Mass incarceration in the United States has been caused by nearly four decades of retributive criminal justice...
Foreign Investment and National Security Challenges in the Data Age: An Assessment of the Current Regime and Recommendations
Irene Yu Volume 74, Issue 3, 959-986 This Note contributes to the growing literature that attempts to grasp the current landscape of international trade and investment norms and policies in the data age. Focusing on the disputes between the United States and China...
Financial Data Governance
Douglas W. Arner, Giuliano G. Castellano, Ēriks K. Selga Volume 74, Issue 2, 235-292 Finance is one of the most digitalized, globalized, and regulated sectors of the global economy. Traditionally technology intensive, the financial industry has been at the forefront...
Deepfakes on Trial: A Call To Expand the Trial Judge’s Gatekeeping Role To Protect Legal Proceedings from Technological Fakery
Rebecca A. Delfino Volume 74, Issue 2, 293-348 Deepfakes—audiovisual recordings created using artificial intelligence (AI) technology to believably map one person’s movements and words onto another—are ubiquitous. They have permeated societal and civic spaces from...
Financial Inclusion Gone Wrong: Securities and Cryptoassets Trading for Children
Nizan Geslevich Packin Volume 74, Issue 2, 349-398 According to studies, money is a major source of anxiety for most Americans. In looking for ways to remedy the source of such anxiety, some believe that increasing children’s financial orientation could help lower...
Considering Vaccination Status
Govind Persad Volume 74, Issue 2, 399-432 This Article examines whether policies—sometimes termed “vaccine mandates” or “vaccine requirements”—that consider vaccination status as a condition of employment, receipt of goods and services, or educational or other...
How Crisis Affects Crypto: Coronavirus as a Test Case
Hadar Y. Jabotinsky & Roee Sarel Volume 74, Issue 2, 433-488 Everybody is talking about cryptocurrencies. These digital tokens, which started in a one-asset market, have swiftly ballooned into a massive and diverse “cryptomarket.” The cryptomarket is still mostly...
Deferring Intellectual Property Rights in Pandemic Times
Peter K. Yu Volume 74, Issue 2, 489-550 This Article examines an unprecedented proposal that India and South Africa submitted to the World Trade Organization (WTO) in October 2020, which called for a waiver of more than thirty provisions in the Agreement on...
The Latest Interface: Using Data Privacy as a Sword and Shield in Antitrust Litigation
Sammi Chen Volume 74, Issue 2, 551-582 The new and growing intersection between data privacy and antitrust uses data privacy as both a sword and shield against antitrust liability. On one hand, large technology firms have begun using privacy as a business...
Mistreatment and Exploitation of Skilled Foreign Workers Through H- Visa Precarity
Isha Vazirani Volume 74, Issue 2, 583-606 The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) announced that beginning on May 26, 2015, certain H-4 dependents of H-1B nonimmigrants would be eligible to apply for an Employment Authorization Document (EAD). The H-4 EAD program...
Sacrificing Sovereignty: How Tribal-State Tax Compacts Impact Economic Development in Indian Country
Pippa Browde Volume 74, Issue 1, 1-44 Economic development is a critical component of tribal sovereignty. When a state asserts taxing authority within Indian Country, there is potential for overlapping, or juridical, taxation over the same transaction. Actual or even...
A Tokenized Future: Regulatory Lessons from Crowdfunding and Standard Form Contracts
Darian M. Ibrahim Volume 74, Issue 1, 45-78 This Article examines the world of risk investing in the cryptoeconomy. The broader crypto market is booming despite the latest downturn. People and institutions are buying in. The question is now how to regulate it. This...
“Cancel Culture” and Criminal Justice
Steven Arrigg Koh Volume 74, Issue 1, 79-122 This Article explores the relationship between two normative systems in modern society: “cancel culture” and criminal justice. It argues that cancel culture—a ubiquitous phenomenon in contemporary life—may rectify...
The Unfulfilled Promise of Environmental Constitutionalism
Amber Polk Volume 74, Issue 1, 123-180 The political push for the adoption of state-level “green amendments” in the United States has gained significant traction in just the last couple of years. Green amendments add an environmental right to a state’s constitution....
The Cost of Survival for Insulin-Dependent Diabetics
Nikol Nesterenko Volume 74, Issue 1, 181-206 Insulin, an injectable drug discovered about 100 years ago that now costs less than $5 to manufacture, is currently sold between $300 and $500 in the United States. The continuously growing price forces many...
Forensic Linguistics: Science or Fiction?
Abigail Shim Volume 74, Issue 1, 207-234 The history of linguistics is meager and splintered due to the subject’s interdisciplinary nature. In the postwar era, the discipline attempted to revive as a scientific one, spearheaded by Noam Chomsky and his theory of...